One thing that always amused me were those proofs that appeared to be true, but which had some patently untrue conclusion, such as 2 = 1. I'm curious how many such proofs people here know. I'll start off with one of the classics:
a + b = c
4a + 4b = 4c
5c = 5a + 5b
4a + 4b + 5c = 5a + 5b + 4c
4a + 4b  4c = 5a + 5b  5c
4(a + b  c) = 5(a + b  c)
4 = 5
The reason this one is false is fairly simple, but not all such proofs are so easy. Does anyone know some better proofs of false statements?
Fun False Proofs

 Posts: 29
 Joined: Mon Jun 07, 2004 11:11 pm

 Posts: 446
 Joined: Wed Jun 02, 2004 11:05 pm

 Posts: 145
 Joined: Sun Jun 13, 2004 11:43 am
 Location: Caltech
Ah yes, I remember that one. Don't forget the car example...
Also, here's another more mathematicallyoriented proof:
Also, here's another more mathematicallyoriented proof:
Code: Select all
x^2 = x + ... + x
x times
d/dx(x^2) = d/dx(x + ... + x)
x times
2x = 1 + ... + 1
x times
2x = x
2 = 1
For the record, I don't actually know anything. Not even this.
Ever wondered what being a Caltech undergrad was like?
[url=http://caltizzle.caltech.edu]caltizzle.caltech.edu[/url]
Ever wondered what being a Caltech undergrad was like?
[url=http://caltizzle.caltech.edu]caltizzle.caltech.edu[/url]

 Posts: 202
 Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2004 4:37 am
 Location: At a theater near you

 Posts: 5
 Joined: Mon Jun 07, 2004 2:48 am
 Location: Cockburn
Just want to say that the symbol for pi looks bloody awful in my browserZombified wrote:Euler's formula:
exp(iπ) + 1 = 0
exp(iπ) = 1
(exp(iπ))^2 = (1)^2
exp(2iπ) = 1
log exp(2iπ) = log 1
2iπ = 0
π = 0
My favourite false proof is the one that you've spent months working on. You've checked it, rechecked it and are absolutely sure that it's correct. Then some smart assed undergrad points out an obvious counter example. Seen way too many of those!
Pacifism is easy when one is masochistic

 Posts: 634
 Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2004 7:07 am